Anime Review: Clannad

The anime Clannad and Clannad After Story are the types of anime you would categorize as a slice of life high school story. It can also be seen as the usual harem genre anime where you have one guy surrounded by various gorgeous women to choose from. One guy amidst pretty girls with different types of personalities to potentially have a relationship with is a common plot device found in anime. Except when you watch both seasons of Clannad and Clannad After Story in its entirety you realize that this series goes much deeper than what is first presented on the surface. I’m going to review the first season of Clannad in this post and in a later post I will review Clannad After Story and give my entire opinion of the series as a whole in the later post.

The entire Clannad series is based on the Japanese visual novel game of the same name. The main character of the series is Tomoya Okazaki, a third year high school student who is a bit of a loner and considered a delinquent in school along with his only friend Youhei Sunohara. Tomoya goes through his high school experience not caring about anything and resenting the life he currently lives. He hates his school, his town, and his father. Tomoya is biding his time until graduation when he can finally move onto the next phase in his life.

One day on his way to school Tomoya encounters a girl named Nagisa Furukawa. He finds her lingering at the bottom of the hill leading up to their school surrounded by cherry blossom trees. Nagisa for some reason is rooted to the spot she’s in, unable to continue the walk all the way to their school. As Tomoya walks past Nagisa he overhears her mumble, “Anpan,” to herself. Her strange mumbling is then followed by a little speech, not noticing Tomoya who stops just beside her. She talks about how she loves her school and what she hopes to get out of it. She ends the speech with a question without really expecting an answer for it. Tomoya, without thinking, answers Nagisa’s question which alerts her to his presence. He gives an honest but helpful answer to her question and urges her to come with him to finish the rest of the walk to their school.

This little, seemingly insignificant encounter between Tomoya and Nagisa becomes very important throughout the series and even more so in Clannad After Story. When Tomoya decides to talk to Nagisa that day, he finds himself also opening up the possibility of letting other people into his life he wouldn’t otherwise have done. This is where the typical harem part of the anime comes in. Tomoya meets all these batch of other girls who are obvious candidates for Tomoya to pursue a potential relationship with aside from Nagisa.

You have the identical twins Kyou and Ryou Fujibayashi whose personalities are as different as night and day. While Kyou is unabashed and a straight to the point kind of girl, her twin sister Ryou is quiet and a little shy. Kotomi Ichinose is the school’s girl genius who spends her entire time at the library studying other subjects at her leisure as she is exempt from attending any actual classes in the school because of her insanely high scores in the standardized exams. Tomoyo Sakagami is the tough and intimidating transfer student who has to demonstrate just how strong she really is whenever Tomoya’s friend Youhei insists on doing a battle of strength with her which usually ends with Youhei beaten up and flying to the other side of the hallway. And finally, there is Fuko Ibuki who spends most of her time alone carving starfish out of blocks of wood.

All these girls have their own individual story arcs and problems they have to go through or deal with, which Tomoya happens to be the guy to help resolve their issues. Although this anime may look like the protagonist is presented with the issue of, “Which girl do I choose?” type of plot it actually has a focus. It becomes very obvious that the canon couple to root for in this series is Tomoya and Nagisa.

Rather than let the encounter on the hill be the last time they ever interact with each other, Tomoya finds Nagisa again sitting alone in the school courtyard eating lunch. He finds himself approaching her again to talk to her. Tomoya learns how Nagisa is actually one year older than him and she had to repeat her third year because she fell gravely ill the previous year. Her new third year sees Nagisa lonely and without any friends because all the friends she made last year had already graduated from school. She’s also determined to try and start a drama club where she would put together and perform plays for the school.

The entire first season of Clannad is about how Tomoya encourages Nagisa to make her high school experience the best one she could ever want, and helps her re-establish the drama club at school with the help of the other girls in the series. Along the way you get to see Nagisa’s family life in contrast to Tomoya’s life. He experiences what it’s like to be a part of a normal (maybe a little eccentric at times) and loving family through Nagisa. Tomoya slowly starts to warm up to others and drops his attitude of “me against the world” and actually starts to care about others.

Tomoya & Nagisa

The best part of this season is the friendship you see unfold between Nagisa and Tomoya. The two of them are quite different. Both have their own issues to sort out which they do together. Nagisa has self-confidence issues and a fear of thinking she may not be good enough to do anything. Tomoya has issues with finding something in life to care enough about and finding happiness among the sadness in his life, such as disappointments with his father and the blame he puts on his father for the injury that halted Tomoya’s basketball career in school. These two help and encourage each other to see the potential in themselves and then draw it out. Tomoya helps instill the confidence Nagisa needs to make friends and put together a wonderful play for the school. Nagisa shows Tomoya that life isn’t all drab as it appears to be. She proves to him that there is beauty to be found in living life. Of course, the friendship eventually turns into one of love.

The deepening of their friendship into something more progresses naturally and with plenty of subtlety. I like the slow progression into the next stage of their relationship. It takes both of them a while to realize that their friendship is transforming into something else, but the viewer already knows what’s coming based on actions you see. In Episode 18 of the anime, Nagisa accidentally gets hit by a stray tennis ball. When the player approaches Nagisa to see if she’s all right and attempts to lend her a hand to help her to the nurse’s office, Tomoya who is already tending to Nagisa slaps away the player’s hand with his arm. The reaction surprises himself, Tomoyo, Ryou, and Kyou. Tomoya, without addressing the player about his reaction to the offered help from the guy, turns back to Nagisa and tells her that they should go to the nurse’s office to have her leg checked out. The scene ends with Tomoya slowly helping Nagisa to the nurse’s office. It becomes clear to Tomoyo, Ryou, and Kyou that Tomoya has fallen in love with Nagisa even though he doesn’t see it himself.

There are other little scenes like that one scattered throughout the anime, but I definitely like the scene I described from episode 18. Tomoya’s overprotective side kicks in and he’s the first one to come to Nagisa’s aid. I think Tomoya pushing the player’s hand away from Nagisa not only shows how much he really cares for Nagisa, but just how much the idea of seeing Nagisa hurt by someone else angers him without expressing it vocally. He really wants to shield her from everything in that moment.

Tomoya and Nagisa as a couple really compliment each other. They need each other without realizing just how much they depend on one another for support. It isn’t just one individual who is the rock in the relationship. The two of them are equally each other’s rocks. Nagisa at times sees herself as the weakling, but Tomoya thinks the opposite of her. He sees her as the strongest person he has ever known and really is in awe of her. Just like Tomoya doesn’t think highly of himself, Nagisa sees a warm and caring person who doesn’t give himself the chance to show it to people more often.

This is why the opening scene of the anime where Nagisa and Tomoya meet for the first time is significant. The surroundings from Tomoya’s perspective is all gray and drab. His world is bleak and depressing. You kind of see Tomoya living his life as if he’s a robot. No emotions and no feeling. Then he meets Nagisa and the colors flicker behind his gray world to suddenly become vivid and beautiful right before his eyes. His gray world is now saturated in color. The cherry blossoms are a lovely shade of pink and the sky is the bluest he has ever seen it been. It’s fitting that their first encounter with each other happens in the spring. It’s literally a new beginning for both of them and the experiences that are waiting for them are done together. Seasons also play a huge part in the series. The anime is heavy with symbolism and it’s quite easy to want to analyze this anime to death.

Overall, the first season of Clannad is a joy to watch because of the relationships developed in this series. There are so many joyous and sad moments in this anime. It pulls at a viewer’s heart strings, and I know I have teared up quite a bit during some of them. At first when a friend introduced me to the series, I didn’t think I would like it. The few slice of life animes I have seen haven’t really caught my interest. I usually ended up bored with a series before dropping it all together. I’m really glad I gave this one a try. If you enjoy animes with good character relationships, watching friendships turn into love, and catching subtle symbolism in an anime and how it relates to the bigger story then you may want to add this anime to your list of things to watch. I highly recommend this moving anime series.

Reviewer Rating: 10/10

13 thoughts on “Anime Review: Clannad

  1. I haven’t watched this one. Like you, I thought I wouldn’t like it. In particular, two things kept me away. The art, which gave me strong moe vibes, and how super popular it was. I think ever since trying a few overrated series (Lucky Star, Fruits Basket, etc.) and really disliking them, I’ve been super wary of anything that seems especially popular and has big moe elements. However, I’m willing to at least give this a try. I’ve sat through some stuff I thought was pretty bland just to finish it off, so no excuse for me to at least not try this to see for myself. 🙂

    1. I really didn’t think I would like it when my friend showed it to me. It looked pretty generic and uninteresting in the first opening moments. I’m really not attracted to too many slice of life animes as I get bored with the plot or the characters weren’t interesting enough for me to keep watching. But when I kept watching a few more episodes of this one then I realized there was something endearing and moving about it. The best part of the series is the second season which is Clannad After Story. Most of the heart and emotion is really in the second half. There is also some strange scenes of a girl and her robot thrown in between the main plot stuff in the series, which seems random but actually has some significance by the end of the second season. In fact, reading blog posts and forum discussions about the end of the entire series have left some people split in opinion. Some like the way it ended and some hated it. The ones who enjoyed it and played the game said the ending of the series is in keeping with how the game plays out. Overall, definitely give the series a try. 😉

  2. Oh god, I was already planning on watching this series, but now I have to watch it even more! This really isn’t my type of thing to watch, but I actually came across a scene from this series by pure chance on Youtube and I was very nearly crying my eyes out. I had only watched that one snippet of about five minutes and I felt like I had just watched a full anime series that sucked out my soul.
    Thanks for the review! Now I know what I can expect without really knowing exactly what is going to happen! I sincerely hope that I will not be mopping up a river of tears by the end of this!

    1. You are very welcome! 😀 Yes, this series is so heartwrenching! You’ll need a box of tissues on hand as you watch the series. Especially Clannad After Story! My goodness is that season enough to put you through the emotional ringer, but it’s so satisfying character developmentwise and emotionally. The series stayed with me long after I had finished watching the entire thing. This anime ended up being one of my favorites.

  3. has just finished watching clannad but dunno why I found no interesting plot in this anime at all. for slice of life genre, I recommend natsume yuujinchou series better than this one. I\’m wondering why so many people love this anime and recommend it, even gave high grade in some anime forums, but I just don\’t get it. and why on the last episode tomoya going out with tomoyo while I think he’s just building his relationship with nagisa?

    1. It’s actually following the game the anime is based on. It’s pretty much like a dating sims type game from what I’ve read. I haven’t personally played the game myself. As for the last episode of the anime, the Tomoyo episode would be considered an alternate universe type of episode. This episode has no relation to the rest of the series itself whatsoever. It’s kind of like a “what if” scenario.

      Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I really enjoyed the characters and the story, and I usually don’t care for slice of life animes in general. I really got caught up in how the characters developed as individuals, and how Tomoya and Nagisa’s relationship grew naturally instead of it feeling forced. To each their own I guess. Sometimes what everyone believes is the best anime series ever, others will view it as mediocre or overhyped. Depends on what someone expected to get out of the story.

  4. Clannad is one of those animes you shouldn’t always judge just because of the category it’s in. I made the same mistake and I regretted it. I trudged through the first season wondering why so many people liked it and I thought that there were other slice of life animes that were much better. Then I watched After Story and my opinion changed completely. I was kind of annoyed that I had to get through an entire first season just to get to the good stuff, because in all honesty, the first season was incredibly boring and the plot was too overused, like koha said, it was uninteresting and felt like it didn’t really have a storyline at all. I figured the whole story was in After Story, that’s why it’s called that. I do highly reccommend this anime and moe shouldn’t put you off once you’ve got used to it. Clannad has really lovely animation in general. The watercolours used for this anime are gorgeous.

    1. Thanks for commenting! Yeah, between the first season and second season of Clannad, After Story is in fact my favorite of the two. I didn’t mind the first season too much, but I can see how it can be slow paced and almost lacking in a plot. The first season almost feels like tiny snapshots of a life without any real substance to keep a viewer engaged. However, viewing After Story makes the first season half of the story really come together. You find out that the heart of the story is the idea of family and the relationship between Nagisa and Tomoya. I also think they raised the emotional bar really high in After Story. It has been a long time since an anime truly made me cry. It was heartbreaking and uplifting at the same time.

      I do agree that you can’t overlook a series without giving it a try first. Sometimes a story doesn’t come together until much later. And yes, the anime is a gorgeous kaleidoscope of colors. It’s one of those series that is wonderful to gaze at.

  5. This is definitely my number one anime series i have ever watched the way it tugs on your heartstrings is just like nothing else this is one of the few anime that have ever been able to make me cry man.

  6. Same here. I never expected so much from this anime when I started. I was just not a fan of its animation style, but I did try it anyway to judge it myself. And it grew on me. It has a great story line. You get engaged with all the characters. The arcs are all great. Damn my fav is Fuku-chan’s. and then when I thought I have already cried enough for the first season, After Story gripped my heart, I literally cried with tissues all over my bed. Especially Tomoya’s story. How he felt and dealt with all the emotions… was so realistic..take it from me who had the same issues … it was like seeing my life out there in the tv (though there were minor differences but looking at how the whole situation was shown, it was so real.) There is always a thin line for love and hate. Clannad was able to capture that. And Nagisa despite being introduced as a sickly child throughout the series , I truly rooted for her and believed with all of my heart that she was a strong person. (disclaimer: I hate weak female protaganists) but Nagisa was so different. She was emotionally strong. I gotta give her that.

    1. I actually really liked the animation style, but as I’ve mentioned in this post, I’m not usually interested in watching slice of life animes. This one turned out to be so much more than what it appears. It’s surprisingly deep and I feel like the amount of symbolism this anime has is enough to write a critical assessment of the themes that run throughout much of the show. It has been years since I’ve watched the anime, but I definitely would go back and rewatch it if I had the chance. I also agree that Nagisa is a really strong female character despite her weakened physical state. She’s one character who’s capable of taking care of herself, but her relationship with Tomoya makes them the ultimate example of a couple whose love is one of equals and unconditional love.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.